RATING RULES

How do I rate books?

When it comes to rating books, I use a combination of key factors to evaluate my overall reading experience. Everyone has their own criteria, and ratings can vary widely in interpretation—some see 3 stars as solid, while others consider it lacking. Similarly, some reviewers give 5 stars more freely, while others reserve them for exceptional reads. Here's how I approach my ratings:

What I Consider When Rating Books

🖊 Storyline and Plot Development:
I evaluate how engaging and well-structured the story is. Predictable plots may lose points unless executed brilliantly, while unique twists can elevate the book.

🖊 Character Depth and Growth:
Relatable, dynamic characters are essential. I value characters that evolve naturally and leave a lasting impression.

🖊 Writing Style:
The author’s ability to craft vivid, fluid prose that evokes emotion plays a big role in my rating.

🖊 Originality and Creativity:
A book that stands out for its fresh ideas or perspective always earns extra points.

 🖊 Emotional Impact and Memorability:
Does the book make me laugh, cry, or think deeply? Memorable books often linger in my mind long after I finish them.

🖊 Pacing and Engagement:
How quickly I read the book and whether it kept me hooked are important considerations.

🖊 Accuracy and Genre Expectations:
If the book involves historical facts or technical details, accuracy matters. I also assess how well it meets the expectations of its genre.

🖊 Sequel Comparison:
For sequels, I consider how it stacks up against earlier books in the series. Does it maintain or exceed the standard?

🖊 Moral Message or Themes:
A thoughtful, meaningful message can elevate my perception of the book.

I follow a thoughtful 5-star rating system, with half-star increments to account for those books that fall between two ratings. After finishing a book, I first reflect on whether I would recommend it to someone. If the answer is yes, the rating starts at 3 stars or higher. If not, it begins at 1 or 2 stars. Here’s how I break down my ratings:

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ – Exceptional

A truly outstanding book that I couldn’t stop thinking or talking about. These books leave a lasting impression and often become personal favorites.

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ – Excellent

A highly enjoyable read that I would enthusiastically recommend to others. It was very well-done but just shy of being extraordinary.

⭐️⭐️⭐️ – Good

A decent book with a balance of positives and flaws. While I enjoyed aspects of it, it didn’t quite reach the level of a favorite.

⭐️⭐️ – Disappointing

This book had some redeeming qualities, but overall, it didn’t resonate with me. It might appeal to others, but it wasn’t to my taste.

⭐️ – Unenjoyable

A book I struggled to finish—or didn’t finish at all. It didn’t meet my expectations and failed to keep me engaged. This system allows me to evaluate books fairly while also reflecting my personal reading experience.